At first glance, consignment and thrift shops are one and the same. However, these two secondhand retail experiences cater to slightly different preferences and needs (here’s a good breakdown).
As the resell market grows in popularity, it’s no surprise that we’re seeing even more opportunities for people to easily (and sustainably) give their unwanted things a second home.
It’s never been easier to shop and sell secondhand pieces (we love celebrating this type of good news — if you couldn’t already tell)!
With over a decade of experience in buying and selling vintage treasures — and as the proud owner of my very own online thrift shop — I’ve got some insight into the world of selling secondhand goods online.
I’ve gathered some of the best online consignment shops out there, hoping that it brings you closer to finding your go-to secondhand shop and discovering the joy of participating in the circular economy!
Short on time? Here’s a quick breakdown of our top picks:
Top Picks: Online Consignment Stores
Plus 18 more…
By the way, some of the links in this article are affiliate links, which means if you make a purchase after clicking a link, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you!
Elevate Your Style with Online Consignment Shops: Our Top Picks
Poshmark
Poshmark, with over 80 million registered users, is a leading social e-commerce platform for buying and selling clothes, accessories, and household goods. This user-friendly platform not only makes the consignment process really easy to navigate, but it also helps folks create compelling listings and manage orders, shipping, and customer communication. (It’s one of my go-to resell platforms!)
Its emphasis on curated recommendations and personalized shopping experiences benefits consignors by aligning their inventory with relevant categories, brands, and styles (looking to sell or buy an outfit for Taylor Swift’s Eras tour? They’ve got you covered). This targeted exposure increases the odds of connecting with the right audience and selling your pieces quickly!
A reason why Poshmark is one of my go-to secondhand marketplaces is because of its community of sellers who share tips, advice, and success stories. (I can’t tell you how encouraging some of these resellers were to me while I was first navigating the resale landscape!)
Vinted
Vinted is a global online secondhand marketplace powered by a massive community of over 45 million members. Consignors can easily create listings, upload product photos, and provide detailed descriptions for adult and kid’s clothing, accessories, homeware, and pet care items.
The platform provides consignors with a safe, user-friendly app, visibility, seller protection, and transparent fee structures.
The RealReal
The RealReal is one of the leaders in the online luxury resale market. Its mission is to help reduce the luxury industry’s impact on our planet by offering a global community of people access to certified luxury consignments.
Consignors can easily submit their luxury items through the platform (direct mailing or scheduling a free at-home pickup in select cities). The RealReal’s streamlined process takes care of the logistics, including authentication, pricing, and listing the items for sale.
With in-house experts — horologists, gemologists, art curators, and luxury fashion authenticators — that curate and inspect each piece, The RealReal has established itself as a trusted marketplace for buyers looking for authentic luxury pieces.
thredUp
thredUp offers women’s and kids’ secondhand clothing. As one of the biggest online thrift stores for clothes, this platform caters to people looking for anything “from Gap to Gucci.”
Consignors can request a Clean Out Kit, which includes a prepaid shipping bag, to easily send their items to thredUp for inspection. The platform handles the entire process, from sorting and pricing to photographing and listing the items for sale. This is the perfect option for consignors seeking a quick and effortless way to rehome their clothes.
Stillwhite
Stillwhite is specifically dedicated to those seeking to consign their wedding dresses. Since wedding dresses are traditionally a single-use product, Stillwhite is looking to change that by offering an online marketplace for buyers and sellers to give their beautiful dresses a second (or third, or fourth!) life.
Sellers simply list their wedding dresses by providing details and photos, while shoppers filter through designers, sizes, and styles. This niche focus attracts a targeted audience of brides-to-be who are actively searching for affordable and sustainable wedding gown options.
Designer Revival
Designer Revival specializes in high-end pre-owned designer, vintage, and contemporary clothing, handbags, jewelry, shoes, and accessories. This online consignment marketplace is a proud woman-owned business that employs a diverse team of creatives, and is a part of the Female Founder Collective — a nonprofit supporting women-led organizations.
All products featured on the platform are inspected for brand-specific guidelines and are put through a rigorous authenticity testing process before being sold — shoppers typically tend to trust this platform!
For consignors, Designer Revival offers free at-home pickups for select locations, as well as takes care of all aspects of the consignment process, including pricing, marketing, and customer service. This is a great option for those consignors who don’t want to put in much effort into the consigning process!
BLK MKT Vintage
BLK MKT Vintage is a unique concept shop based in Brooklyn, NY, offering a curated collection of antique and vintage items that celebrate Black history and lived experiences.
The shop, founded by Jannah Handy and Kiyanna Stewart, specializes in collectibles, cast-offs, and curiosities that center Black cultural artifacts. Their collection includes vintage literature, vinyl records, clothing, art, housewares, decor, furniture, and more.
BLK MKT Vintage offers multiple ways for folks to engage with their collection.
Luxury Garage Sale
Luxury Garage Sale is a highly curated online consignment boutique that specializes in luxury designer clothing, accessories, and handbags. It offers authentic, pre-owned pieces from the world’s top luxury brands.
Each product undergoes a rigorous authentication process conducted by experts in the field. Not only does the company tout an effortless selling experience for consignors, but it also offers at-home pickups for those in select cities, as well as cash upfront.
Vestiaire Collective
Vestiaire Collective is a B Corp-certified thrift store available to conscious consumers all over the world. The company is also an active member of groups pushing for a more sustainable fashion system, like, the Ellen MacArthur Foundation, UN Fashion Alliance, and ParisGoodFashion.
With a team of counterfeit experts that checks product authenticity (very important when shopping luxury), Vestiaire Collective’s team provides pricing guidance to professional photo editing in order to help consignors present their items in the best possible light. They also offer consignors up to 85% of their sales (which is way more than others).
Tradesy
Tradesy is an online marketplace for buying and selling luxury secondhand fashion, like clothing, handbags, shoes, and accessories. Tradesy developed smart technology that automatically detects and removes fakes listed on its site with 99.7% accuracy, according to its site.
Consignors list their items on Tradesy, set their own prices, and when an item sells, Tradesy handles the payment processing, shipping, and returns. The platform verifies the authenticity of the items and provides a trusted marketplace for people to engage in consignment.
Mercari
Mercari, like Poshmark and Depop, makes it really easy for people to buy and sell items online (in my opinion, one of the most straightforward platforms out there). With millions of buyers actively on the hunt for secondhand goods, consignors have more visibility and access to a wide audience of potential customers.
Where Mercari differs from similar marketplaces is in its Mercari Local feature — a contactless way of buying and selling products under 50 pounds that are local to you. This platform tries to take away the sketchiness that tends to be associated with local marketplace meetups and instead offers scheduled pickups and door deliveries by its trusted local partners.
The Plus Bus
The Plus Bus is a curated plus-size consignment store for shoppers looking for trendy clothing and accessories. They provide a supportive and inclusive environment for consignors to celebrate every body shape.
What sets The Plus Bus apart from the rest is its commitment to body positivity — providing a safe and supportive environment where consignors can confidently embrace their unique style and connect with shoppers. The company’s in-house buyers carefully select inventory that’s updated weekly on its site and daily through Instagram Live.
Kaiyo
Kaiyo specializes in pre-owned furniture and home decor items. Whether you’re looking to buy or sell, this platform allows those living within the greater New York City, Los Angeles, San Diego, Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Washington D.C. metro areas a chance to shop for good-quality furniture while keeping our planet in mind.
Consignors can sell their furniture to Kaiyo, and the company handles the listing, marketing, and sale of the items on their online platform. Once the item is sold, the seller receives a portion of the proceeds. Kaiyo takes care of the logistics, such as pickup and delivery, making it convenient for both buyers and sellers.
SWOP
SWOP is an Australia-based female-founded clothing consignment store that buys, sells, and trades quality vintage and on-trend clothing. The shop aims to disrupt the wasteful practices of the current fashion industry at large by offering an alternative way to shop.
It offers same-day buying and exchange services, emphasizing high-quality items. SWOP’s qualified buyers purchase clothing and accessories based on current and seasonal trends — considering the cut, color, fabric, and condition.
Grailed
Grailed is a specialized online marketplace for men’s clothing and streetwear. With its niche focus on men’s fashion, the platform offers consignors with an uber-targeted audience of passionate buyers.
Sellers looking to get rid of high-end designer clothing, sneakers, accessories, or vintage pieces gain access to a dedicated community of fashion-savvy folks ready to give their unwanted items a second go.
Kidizen
Kidizen is for parents and caregivers looking to consign their kids gently used clothing, accessories, toys, and gear. It offers a convenient and user-friendly marketplace specifically designed for parents, making it a go-to choice for consignors in the kids’ fashion industry.
While I don’t have kids or sell kid’s clothes, Kidizen app reviews are overwhelmingly positive and highlight its great online community of eco-conscious, supportive parents. Aside from that, the company offers a user-friendly app where you can effortlessly upload photos and descriptions of your items! (So no complicated processes or technical skills are required)
LXRandCo
LXRandCo is another great luxury vintage consignment option that specializes in secondhand designer handbags and accessories. With physical shops scattered throughout the U.S., Canada, Germany, Belgium, and Dubai, this retail shop also has a great online presence. For online shoppers, LXRandCo offers a constantly updated selection of inventory on its site, like watches, handbags, and other high-quality staple pieces.
Each item is carefully inspected and authenticated before being listed for sale — meaning customers feel a little more confident in their online purchase. Whether consignors prefer the in-store experience or online convenience, LXRandCo offers options for both! Sellers can either choose to have their items appraised in one of its locations or submit images online.
Fashionphile
Fashionphile is focused on designer and luxury handbags, offering a wide range of preowned vintage, rare, and limited-edition pieces from top luxury brands. Launched in 1999, the brand has since gained a reputation for its great customer service and its jaw-dropping collection of high-end accessories — including Dior, Bottega Veneta, Loewe, and Old Céline.
When it comes to consignment, sellers receive one of the highest payouts in the industry while simultaneously benefiting from the company’s nicely-packaged presentation and exposure.
While Fashionphile does have boutique locations in Beverly Hills, San Francisco, San Diego, and New York City, its user-friendly app is a standout for customers. Consignors can also track the progress of their consigned items from the moment they arrive until the sale is finalized and payment is issued.
Neutral Ground
Neutral Ground is a carefully curated collection of women’s vintage and designer pieces, offering a unique consignment option for those who specifically love neutral color palettes. Each garment in the collection is thoughtfully selected, ensuring quality and maintaining a modern color palette with neutral tones and the occasional metallic accents.
Although some items may be less than 20 years old (which would not be considered vintage), they are chosen for their rarity, collectibility, or one-of-a-kind nature. This ensures that customers can discover special finds that truly stand out and contribute to the preservation of timeless styles.
Rebag
Rebag is a consignment platform for buying, selling, and trading luxury accessories. Their expertise extends beyond bags to include jewelry, watches, and small leather goods.
Rebag specialists thoroughly inspect and certify each item to ensure quality and authenticity before listing it on its site. Whether you’re looking to consign your beloved designer pieces or discover your next treasured accessory, Rebag offers an easy-to-use platform to find authentic luxury pieces at a fraction of their original prices.
